| You’re all smiles and silly conversations |
| As if this sunny day came just for you |
| You twist your hair, your smile and you turn your eyes away |
| Come on tell me what’s right with you |
| Now it dawns on me probably everybody’s talking |
| There’s something here I’m supposed to realize |
| Your secret’s out and the universe laughs at its joke on me |
| I just caught it in your eyes |
| It’s a beautiful surprise |
| When did you fall in love with me? |
| Was it out of the blue? |
| 'Cause I swear I never knew it |
| When did you let your heart run free? |
| Have you been waiting long? |
| When did you fall in love with me? |
| When did you fall in love? |
| Make your way over here, sit down by this fool and let’s rewind |
| Come on let’s go back and replay all our scenes |
| Point out the hints, the clues, the twists and the smiles this time |
| All the ones that slipped by me |
| I bet my face is red and you can hear my heart pounding |
| Well I guess it don’t matter now that I realize |
| 'Cause baby I missed it then, but I can surely see you now |
| Right here before my eyes |
| You’re my beautiful surprise |
| When did you fall in love with me? |
| Was it out of the blue? |
| 'Cause I swear I never knew it |
| When did you let your heart run free? |
| Have you been waiting long? |
| When did you fall in love with me? |
| When did you fall in love? |
| Was it at the coffee shop? |
| Or was it that morning at the bus stop? |
| When you almost slipped and I caught your hand |
| Or the time we built the snowman? |
| The day at the beach, sandy and warm |
| Or the night with the scary thunderstorm? |
| I never saw the signs |
| And we’ve got to make up for lost time |
| And I can tell now by the way you’re looking at me |
| I better finish this song so my lips will be free |
| Yeah |
| Have you been waiting long? |
| When did you fall in love? |
| I kept you waiting so long |
| When did you fall? |
| Have you been waiting long? |
| When did you fall in love with me? |
| When did you fall in love? |
| Was it at the coffee shop? |
| Or that morning at the bus stop? |
| I never saw the signs |
| No, no |
| 'Cause I’m gonna fall |
| I’m gonna fall |
| I’m about to fall in love |
| And I need to know |
| When did you fall for me? |
| My lips will be free |
| My lips are free |
| My lips are free |